There are so many issues with the NCAA right now that it's hard to really nail down what the worst part is, and the NIL, revenue sharing, etc., are only making things worse. Former Badger great JJ Watt is fed up with how little the NCAA seems to care about the "student" part of the "student-athlete." He jumped onto X the other day and posted a string of concerns around the transfer portal and the overall concern the NCAA has with its athletes.
The NCAA transfer portal opening before March Madness ends (same as football portal opening before bowl season ends) is preposterous.
— JJ Watt (@JJWatt) March 23, 2025
Literally cannibalizing your own sport.
Imagine NFL free agency starting the Monday after Wild Card Weekend…
"Literally cannibalizing your own sport." JJ Watt is irate over how the NCAA is being run
The first bone he has to pick is with the transfer portal. Currently, there are 16 teams left to play in the NCAA D1 Men's Basketball Tournament, and yet the transfer portal opened yesterday. That means that players have a window to move around while the "playoffs" are still ongoing. That's insane. There's even a player from Michigan who's in the Sweet 16 who has jumped into the portal. His season isn't even over, and he's decided to move on.
Watt said this is "cannibalizing your own sport. Imagine NFL free agency starting the Monday after Wild Card Weekend..." When you put it that way, it truly is incredibly insane.
At some point the NCAA needs to drop the “student first, athlete second” charade.
— JJ Watt (@JJWatt) March 24, 2025
Billions of dollars, NIL, transfer portal (free agency), traveling cross-country for midweek games…
Education is not the main focus.
Admit it and call it what it is.
A business.
Run it as such.
He then reflected a bit more and realized that the whole thing is a mess. The "student first, athlete second" messaging that the NCAA promotes is garbage. Evidence is in the way they treat the athletes and how education takes a backseat to athletics.
He clarifies his point by saying that the NCAA needs to stop pretending it's not a business. The mess right now is caused by the NCAA's desire to pretend to be student-focused but act athlete-focused, which creates a ton of confusion. When pushed for clarification by a follower on his social media account, this is exactly Watt's point.
That’s exactly my point.
— JJ Watt (@JJWatt) March 24, 2025
We’ve got kids who aren’t “making money” and will never go pro, yet they are traveling across the country midweek for “conference games”, transferring schools, sacrificing studies for sport, etc.
None of this is about what’s doing best for the student.