Skip to main content

Projecting the future of Wisconsin basketball with the new 5-in-5 rule implemented

A glimpse into the future of Wisconsin basketball.
Wisconsin head coach Greg Gard argues a call during the first half of their quarterfinal game against Illinois in the Big Ten tournament Friday, March 13, 2026 at the United Center in Chicago, Illinois.
Wisconsin head coach Greg Gard argues a call during the first half of their quarterfinal game against Illinois in the Big Ten tournament Friday, March 13, 2026 at the United Center in Chicago, Illinois. | Mark Hoffman/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

After much debate, controversy and conversation, the NCAA finally bit the bullet, implementing a "five-in-five" rule. This new legislation limits the window of a college player's eligibility to five years after one graduates from high school, or for overseas guys looking to come stateside, five years after their 19th birthday. This also removes the redshirt system, forcing athletes to seek out a waiver if they believe they deserve an extra year of eligibility.

For the Wisconsin Badgers, guys like Owen Foxwell will suffer from this as it sheds off a year of eligibility. But for nearly the entire roster outside of him, this rule will prove to be beneficial. Players who would otherwise be graduating this year have now been given an extra year to develop and play for Greg Gard and the Badgers, raising the ceiling of the team even more.

Nolan Winter, Trey Autry and Eian Elmer are now eligible for an extra year of play with Wisconsin that they wouldn't otherwise have, making that 2027-28 season all the more exciting. Now, on top of bringing in two top-100 recruits in Baboucarr Ann and Jalen Brown, the Badgers can potentially add two All-Conference-level talents alongside them, making this one of the most dangerous Wisconsin teams in recent memory.

This Years Concerns

One of the biggest concerns with the Badgers heading into this season is the lack of a self-creator. Winter, Rapp and Elmer have each proven themselves to be solid play finishers, benefiting off the opportunities that others create. Now, with Foxwell in the mix, Wisconsin could, in theory, run the offense through him and let him dish out the ball and lead the offense.

This strategy may work for 35 minutes in every game, but when the going gets tough and the Badgers need a bucket, there is no clear option to turn to like they have had in years past. Obviously, someone could develop into that role, with Elmer, Winter and Rapp being the clear favorites to take that leap. However, until they prove capable, that facet of the Wisconsin offense remains a mystery.

Projecting the Future

Jalen Brow
Wauwatosa West guard Jalen Brown (24) is tied up by Wauwatosa East guard/forward Tommie Muskgrow (4) on a drive in a game Friday, December 12, 2025, at Wauwatosa East High School in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. West won 74-63. | Dave Kallmann / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

That issue, however, is what makes that 2027-28 roster so interesting, as, in theory, Brown and Ann can do just that. Obviously, both men have a ways to go in their development before they are truly ready for the college stage, but both of them have shown flashes of being able to self-create in high volume. Brown more so, as his handle and outside shot are far more polished than Ann's at this stage. But with that said, the flashes Ann has shown as a transition shot creator and even as a passer hint at an extremely high upside.

Nonetheless, Wisconsin has put itself into a position to make a deep playoff push in the very near future, as long as things continue to go according to plan.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations