Skip to main content

John Blackwell’s latest stinker has Wisconsin fans drawing AJ Storr comparisons

John Blackwell continues to struggle at Duke and even Illinois getting some revenge.
ByMark Knight
Nov 13, 2026; Durham, North Carolina, USA;  SIU-Edwardsville Cougars guard Dehrio McCaskill (11) attempts to inbound the ball as Duke Blue Devils guard John Blackwell (13) defends during the first half at Cameron Indoor Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Rob Kinnan-Imagn Images
Nov 13, 2026; Durham, North Carolina, USA; SIU-Edwardsville Cougars guard Dehrio McCaskill (11) attempts to inbound the ball as Duke Blue Devils guard John Blackwell (13) defends during the first half at Cameron Indoor Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rob Kinnan-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Duke is going to be asking Wisconsin for a refund soon on John Blackwell if he continues to no-show, especially in all the big games. This time, it was No. 10 Illinois, a team that wanted Blackwell in the transfer portal. It was the university that his dad played for but never gave him an offer out of high school. Instead, it was Greg Gard who found him and developed him.

This part matters to the story, but more on that in a minute. Because the current comparisons are that Blackwell is simply the new AJ Storr. It's hard to deny that right now, and it may say more about Gard than it does about Blackwell or Storr. First, let's talk about Blackwell versus Illinois.

Against Illinois, Blackwell scored seven points with 2-for-10 from the field and 2-for-8 from behind the arc. He also went 1-for-2 from the line and had three rebounds, an assist, and a turnover. It was a forgettable night for Blackwell, and it followed another forgettable night against SIUE; he went 1-7 with only three points, zero rebounds, and one assist.

In fact, the entire season hasn't been what Duke was hoping for from Blackwell. He's averaging 9.5 points, 2.3 rebounds, and 1 assist per game with a field goal percentage of 34.2%. Yikes.

John Blackwell may not be the right fit for Duke - He's yet to click as a Blue Devil

Related: All signs continue to be extremely encouraging for Braeden Carrington's injury status

So, the comparisons to AJ Storr aren't unfounded and maybe have some credence to them. AJ Storr was a player that Greg Gard found in the portal, a player with a ton of potential but under the radar at St. John's. He became a star at Wisconsin in his only year in Madison, averaging nearly 20 points a game, and was the go-to player for Gard and Wisconsin.

Storr decided to take advantage of his window of opportunity and transfer to Kansas. He immediately fell off, averaging only 6.1 points that season. Storr didn't live up to the potential and wasn't the star that the Jayhawks thought they were getting. He was able to revive his career in the following year at Ole Miss, but the credit was already flying towards Greg Gard.

Gard was doing it again with John Tonje and then again with Nick Boyd. Blackwell was a player discovered out of high school and fit Gard's offensive philosophy to a T, and was able to thrive as a Badger. It appears, at least so far, Duke may be a terrible fit and wasn't the right decision.

Now, before everyone fills up my mentions like last time. Yes, Blackwell is being smart by capitalizing on his opportunity to earn money. Duke was a big bidder and gave him a great contract (or so it is reported), but with a HIGH contract comes HIGH expectations. Those expectations come with writers speculating and wondering if the star player made the right decision.

Would I have made the same decision to pursue a higher income? Sure, but I also would understand it comes with scrutiny. That's part of the gig. And to the Duke fans that wonder why a Badger site is still following along, because this isn't our first rodeo with a star player at Wisconsin struggling at their new stop.

Add us as a preferred source on Google